Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
  • entries
    2
  • comments
    0
  • views
    92

Boardgamecafe.net Meetup Report @ OTK Cheras 2/10/2015– BARONY, ROLL FOR THE GALAXY

ayheng

49 views

The night started with a two player game of Barony between Ivan and Heng

barony_rollftg018.JPG

This game have serious component overproduction issues

barony_rollftg011.JPG

Modular setup tiles

barony_rollftg012.JPG

Game action summary card

barony_rollftg013.JPG

Victory Points tracker

barony_rollftg014.JPG

Control Points tiles

barony_rollftg015.JPG

This game is sort of like chess where positioning and area control matters.

barony_rollftg016.JPG

This is more so in our two player game as each move is met immediately by a countermove.

Castles, Fortresses and Mountains form up choke points and defensive barriers.

Villages give control points to convert to Victory Points. However the catch is that villages can be razed by the opponent to steal those control points from you.

barony_rollftg017.JPG

The challenge is then to time the conversion and also to position those villages in more defensible territory.

As the game is deterministic (no random elements), the thinky and analysis paralysis can get quite bad. However it does reward repeated plays and there are many strategies that a veteran can employ against a beginner.

Next we are joined by Vence for Roll for the Galaxy (RollFTG)!

barony_rollftg0117.JPG

from left: Heng, Vence, Ivan. You can see Sinbad's gang in the background doing other games.

Race for the Galaxy (RaceFTG) is one of my favourite games, but I always felt the teaching time is too long and unnecessarily complex.

So how does RollFTG fare as an apparently shorter dice variant of RaceFTG?

First off - the dice now acts as the resource of the game, so no more huge hand of cards as resources, instead, it is better to get as many dice as possible in this game.

The explore option works differently in that new developments and worlds revealed go to the bottom of your stack and only the top can be worked on.

This is a massive change from RaceFTG as previously you will have a massive hand to pick and choose which tech or world to work on. So RollFTG although won't confuse new players as much with too many options, does feel constricting to a RaceFTG player.

The other major change for the better is to combine trade and consume into the same action called shipping.

Leeching off other player's actions is still a mainstay of RollFTG, however this time, in order to leech effectively, you have to commit dice resources to those actions that you think the other players will play. This is where the more dice you have the better as you have more dice to 'guess' where the other players will go and as an added bonus, mitigate the luck of the die roll.

sturdy dice cup

barony_rollftg019.JPG

the colourful dice!

barony_rollftg0110.JPG

player board

barony_rollftg0111.JPG

player screen cum rules summary

barony_rollftg0112.JPG

action selection board

barony_rollftg0113.JPG

game credit marker

barony_rollftg0114.JPG

player action selection indicator

barony_rollftg0115.JPG

Player starting world plus specialisation (yup, you start with 3 development/world on tableau)

barony_rollftg0116.JPG

allocating dice

barony_rollftg0119.JPG

gaming @ Old Town Whitecoffee = getting fat

barony_rollftg0118.JPG

So what do I think of the game? RollFTG seems to be more streamlined and easier to teach, however the limited exploration option gives the game a different character from RaceFTG. I'll have to try it a few more times and with different player count. At this point in time, RollFTG does seem to be able to coexists with RaceFTG but definitely RollFTG will be my choice to teach to newbies.



0 Comments


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×